You might remember a little while ago I uploaded and a quick animation of a hopping kangaroo [link]. I received a lot of wonderfully helpful comments and have now finished the new and improved version
This is a great animation. I can see where you took the critiques from your last loop and you’ve improved it a lot! I also love the design! The colors and design choices you came up with really hit the mark with referencing Australia.
I’m going to get down to brass tacks though: it doesn’t move all the way like a kangaroo (but it's getting there!). It moves like you might expect it to move if you haven’t actually spent time watching a LOT of videos of kangaroos. It moves like a wolf or cat might move if you stretched it until it looks like a kangaroo – if that makes sense. Let me explain.
First, kangaroos almost never bob their heads. They’re jump is actually quite a lateral movement and not so vertical. Any vertical shock absorbing movement (which is currently showing up in the neck), is taken by the back, between the shoulder and hip. It doesn’t bend up and stretch out, like a typical four-legged animal that’s running; it’s more of a slight rocking movement.
The legs don’t bend so dramatically in the knee, either. Once again, it’s not like a cat or dog jumping. The kangaroo’s knees don’t bend on impact for shock absorption, as in other animals. Instead the toes and hips take most of the shock. As the toes strike the ground, the chest is at it’s lowest tilted point and tail at the highest and it’s thighs are actually moving downwards/ away from its head as its strike. The deepest bend in the kangaroo’s knees are actually on the back end of its stride, when it needs to lift its ankles so it can swing its toes back to the front without tripping. The movement of the legs is much, much wider – they really toss those suckers out in front of them and out behind when they’re on the go!
All in all, I have to say GREAT job though. It’s a hard animal to capture and very different than other animals. I would really encourage you to watch lots and LOTS of videos of kangaroos. Challenge yourself: try to animate as FEW lines as possible to get it to look like it moves like a kangaroo. If you can get the movement down, you obviously already know how to do the rest!
I hope this was helpful (I’m not great a fluffing up a bunch of stuff when people are asking for a critique.) and that my criticism was constructive for you.
Lets begin the moment of truth shall we? I love the whole theme with the kangaroo. It is very original, and just absolutely fascinating! The way it moves makes me feel like I am watching an actual Kangaroo! I also love the color and back round design. The Kangaroo itself seems to move correctly. I know this critique might be a bit confusing, but let me just say that the reason is is that I can not think of words to describe how magnificent it is! I see no flaws really, but I do see some improvement. Maybe add a shadow or maybe some moving background to give a little more detail. That is just what I think. Have a good day or Night! ~ Liza
And I love how you animated the body here, and the way the neck and head move when he jumps. My only criticism is that I think he hesitates a bit too much directly before the actual spring forward. If you watch actual kangaroos when they make that spring, there's barely a pause before the legs kick back and the body goes forward. If you took maybe a frame or two out of that pause, it should look a lot better.
I’m going to get down to brass tacks though: it doesn’t move all the way like a kangaroo (but it's getting there!). It moves like you might expect it to move if you haven’t actually spent time watching a LOT of videos of kangaroos. It moves like a wolf or cat might move if you stretched it until it looks like a kangaroo – if that makes sense. Let me explain.
First, kangaroos almost never bob their heads. They’re jump is actually quite a lateral movement and not so vertical. Any vertical shock absorbing movement (which is currently showing up in the neck), is taken by the back, between the shoulder and hip. It doesn’t bend up and stretch out, like a typical four-legged animal that’s running; it’s more of a slight rocking movement.
The legs don’t bend so dramatically in the knee, either. Once again, it’s not like a cat or dog jumping. The kangaroo’s knees don’t bend on impact for shock absorption, as in other animals. Instead the toes and hips take most of the shock. As the toes strike the ground, the chest is at it’s lowest tilted point and tail at the highest and it’s thighs are actually moving downwards/ away from its head as its strike. The deepest bend in the kangaroo’s knees are actually on the back end of its stride, when it needs to lift its ankles so it can swing its toes back to the front without tripping. The movement of the legs is much, much wider – they really toss those suckers out in front of them and out behind when they’re on the go!
All in all, I have to say GREAT job though. It’s a hard animal to capture and very different than other animals. I would really encourage you to watch lots and LOTS of videos of kangaroos. Challenge yourself: try to animate as FEW lines as possible to get it to look like it moves like a kangaroo. If you can get the movement down, you obviously already know how to do the rest!
I hope this was helpful (I’m not great a fluffing up a bunch of stuff when people are asking for a critique.) and that my criticism was constructive for you.
Good luck! ☺
~ Liza
The Artist has requested Critique on this Artwork
Please sign up or login to post a critique.